Television Is So Dumb
Monday, September 21, 2009 at 02:17 PM EDT
My daughter spent 4 1/2 months living with her father this last winter and spring. In our house, she did not watch television and movies were limited. At his house, she was given a television in her room. The differences since she spent those four months watching the stupid box are enormous. She was sold on corporate culture, began to believe most advertising (although she is also skeptical if the ad isnâ€™t cute and geared toward selling to a ten-year-old), and generally thinks all the television that was left on at all hours of the day was entertaining.
I donâ€™t know if I did her any favors keeping this shit from her if seeing it makes it so palatable. Yet I still would not change that most of her life has not been spent in front of the idiot box. The first couple of weeks after she came home she kept claiming she was â€œboredâ€ and wanting me to entertain her. Then she slipped back into her home routine and started knitting and creating plays for her stuffed animals and reading, doing all those things with her mind she did not do when she had an idiot box to stare at.
It blows my mind that parents find the thing â€œeducationalâ€ and â€œinteractive.â€ It might present some content or ask questions the child answers, but the child is still sitting there on her butt, being told or asked by flashing movements, more loud and ugly these days. The child is not out making the discovery on her own, thinking and creating, truly interacting.
Milla proved to us her ability to create and design and think on her own, using her own mind. She planned and executed an amazing dog wedding between our dog and the neighbor dog, Luke. She designed and sewed Avaâ€™s gown and veil. She made a marriage certificate with a shiny, glittery, yellow seal. There was a guest list for us all to sign. She wrote the vows and planned the ceremony. She chose the music for all aspects of the ceremony, including the processional, after the vows, the first dances, and the reception. She designed decorations and hung them in the yard, Ava and Luke Tie the Knot. All of it was thorough and amazing. Sheâ€™s ten. This is what she does instead of staring at the television.
I was thinking about all of this this morning. There was an ad on Danâ€™s computer before something he was watching on Huffington Post. Milla saw it and said it was a funny commercial. She had seen it at her dadâ€™s. She told us the premise. To me it sounded so damn stupid and ridiculous, nothing funny at all, and I felt sad that she found this shit she had seen on the idiot box amusing. However I long ago realized that her life is hers to live, not mine to control. I can provide certain influences, but so do so many other things and ultimately she will make her own choices. I can only hope that the influences Iâ€™ve provided help her to be a functional, healthy, and happy adult. Thatâ€™s the thing about parenting, if we do our jobs, this is exactly how it should be.
This article originally appeared on Lara Gardner's Weblog.